34
« on: June 26, 2013, 07:49:52 am »
Dear all,
On youtube I recently came across what was called a PlaneShift "review", and the reaction of an (by now ex-) PlaneShift player to it. While as a single incident this is probably without too much importance, it made me think a lot about how the PlaneShift community represents itself to the outside world, and I would like to discuss this here.
I write "review", because it was of poor quality, scratching but the surface of PlaneShift, and ignoring many crucial points. The author had not even fully mastered the interface, and one of the highlights was when he called PlaneShift "too English". (Both "review" and answer were in German.)
Such a "review" is not nice, but the reaction to it was a pure desaster, since the ex-player insulted the author and put forth some absurd claims about the state of the game ("you can do everything now", "there are always 400 people online").
This kind of reaction, even if the anger behind is understandable up to a certain point, can easily create the impression that PlaneShift players are rude and stupid nerds who are unable to handle criticism. While some of the members of the PlaneShift community are certainly exactly like this, most of us are not.
We should also keep in mind that whenever we write about PlaneShift, we are not only writing in our own name. We represent the whole PlaneShift Community.
I replied both to the original author, and to the ex-player, trying to set some things straight.
Below please find some points that IMHO should be respected when talking about PlaneShift. Please do comment about the list - what should be added, where am I wrong?
* Be polite. (One should think this is obvious, but see the example above.)
* Be honest.
* Accept justified criticism.
* Show some sense of humour.
* Do not claim knowledge you do not have, but invite people to come and see for themselves.
* Talk about the strengths of PlaneShift, without denying its weaknesses.
* Mention that PlaneShift is totally free, not just partly free as so many other games.
* PlaneShift is and probably always will be under constant development.
* PlaneShift has a strong community.
* The Dev team is hiring.
Thank you for your opinions. It is important that we present PlaneShift well, so as to attract new people.
Gonger