I think noob worlds are a good idea, even if it\'s one city, or island, which has only a one way ticket out.
Farther more you mentioned crafting and learning the game\'s interface, so for example the ticket out costs some money and say a simple monster trophy, so people have to learn how to make money and the basics of combat - and once they learn enough it\'s represented in enough money for the one-way ticket :]
I personally hate how people treat noobs in most games. face it, we were all noobs at some point, and i hate to break it to you, we are still all bloody noobs who think they aren\'t ones
If the game doesn\'t have a noob world, there will *always* be new noobs, and there will be a constant question chatter, which, as much as i don\'t mind helping here and there, i think it substracts from everyone\'s roleplaying atmosphere.
Thumbs up Covetski =]
That poses some problems... say you invite a friend to planeshift and need him to join and get to your guild HQ so he can get a position before someone else fills it, like guild artist which doesn\'t have as much bearing on their in-game stats. The other person will be at an obvious advantage, making your friend lose the position to a presumably inferior candidate.
Also, imagine what would happen if all the annoying \"spoon-feed me info! Now!\" type newbies were locked up in one world... when/if you get the desire to create a second character you will have to wade thru a sea of those types of people to get through and out of the world. Not a very elegant solution from that standpoint....
As much as i hate to start flame wars, i just want to share with everyone how much i feel sick after reading this thing.
So noob world aren\'t ok, because they don\'t allow your noobish friend to get to your 1337 guild and get a headstart on other noobs.
And i really shed a tear that you\'ll have to play a few hours in a noob world, must be a traumatic experience.
Of course you wouldn\'t think of the bright side where veteran players could help beginners a bit while they are doing their chores to get back to the mainland.