Bear with me, because I'm a complete tech-idiot.

If I could actually find the logs I might have figured it out (apparently, my path is a bit different, because I don't have a planeshift folder in my applications support folder. The only planeshift folder I have is in applications, and none of the folders in it seem to be what I'm looking for, though being completely tech-unsaavy, I'm going on my best guesswork on most of this.) but I couldn't, so I didn't. Instead, I attempted to talk to Xargon - he told me to see the other teachers and then bring the three items, which I had, but when I tried to give him the first one the system told me he didn't need that item. So I'm guessing Orphia isn't done with me. So, I made a new character and relaunched the tutorial, just to see if following the walk-through exactly in the case of Orphia did me any good. It didn't. I'm still stuck there, attempting any and all word cues I can think of.