Yep. Try it like crime in real life 
Have you visited youtube lately? Chances are you were stealing....
A game is a simulation. If the simulation were 100% accurate, then it would be reality. Picking on the simulation for not matching reality 100% is flawed, annoying and reactionary. There will be endless details that one can pick at forever to cause consternation and disruption in others. Some characters have mastered this tactic.
It wouldn't be reality, because your actions in a game don't have consequences to your real life. Even if all the dynamics are realistic, the dynamics are defined by the separate and escapist nature of the activity. People behave differently because of it.
That sums it up. generally speaking, crime is crime no matter the setting though.
Is it really? Even in the real world, not all crimes are equal, and not all criminals are equal.