How do you all feel about a NPC militia in some of the more law-abiding town patrolling or standing guard, watching for law-breaking activities.
Say if someone picked a pocket in the middle of a street and failed a check, the militia man off to the side would notice. You would spend an hour in jail, (you could log off while this hour is taking place), assigned a fine, and sent on your way.
I think this would add a more realistic element to the game. Also, it would make a thief really earn their money. A MUD I used to play had something similar to this, and it made thieving much more fun. Hey, you could actually get caught! In that game, if you didnt have the money to pay your fine, that character was in jail for the rest of his/her life. It really adds excitement to the stealthy arts

Thanks for reading!
Edit: Also, this would put some control on PK and PvP in towns. Any initiator of fighting would have to deal with 5 or 6 very skilled guards. Makes these activities go into a realm where newbies arent getting slaughtered right and left.