a good guild for a newb?

[zanzibar]

Originally posted by AendarCallenlasse
Kada\'s List represents the oldest guilds, the biggest guilds, and the best guilds.  The guilds that are on that list have been around long enough to know PS and to know the people of PS and that fact makes it a very good place to start if you are new to PS.

It used to, but it\'s hella out of date.  Plus, it doesn\'t include secret guilds, secretive guilds, or initiatives.

[Shadowfax]

Originally posted by zanzibar
It used to, but it\'s hella out of date.  Plus, it doesn\'t include secret guilds, secretive guilds, or initiatives.

Haha sorry but how can a guild be secret if it is posted clearly on Kada\'s list?

You prob don\'t see that many members of the guilds of the realm in-game because unlike the newer guilds they don\'t just accept every newb that comes along into the guild.

And the CV is not set up in game, or atleast not that I know of, so you have to know who the members are in order to spot them.

Edit: And if you think Kada\'s list is out of date, you can always look at the new guild list Aendar has set up, which is stickied at the top of the guilds forum.

[zanzibar]

Originally posted by Shadowfax

Originally posted by zanzibar
It used to, but it\'s hella out of date.  Plus, it doesn\'t include secret guilds, secretive guilds, or initiatives.

Haha sorry but how can a guild be secret if it is posted clearly on Kada\'s list?

You prob don\'t see that many members of the guilds of the realm in-game because unlike the newer guilds they don\'t just accept every newb that comes along into the guild.

And the CV is not set up in game, or atleast not that I know of, so you have to know who the members are in order to spot them.

Edit: And if you think Kada\'s list is out of date, you can always look at the new guild list Aendar has set up, which is stickied at the top of the guilds forum.

Right... a lot of guilds were lost during the wipe and never regrouped.  Others don\'t exist in-game as actual guilds.  And there are secret guilds which are none-the-less well known, or at least known.

[Levski]

Blitzers are still around ;-).

You could always look at Aendar\'s new list.

[zanzibar]

Originally posted by Levski
Blitzers are still around ;-).

You could always look at Aendar\'s new list.

The problem is that it\'s merely a catalogue of guilds with descriptions the guild made about themselves.  Each guild will try to reflect on itself in the best possible light, regardless of its reputation in the community.

If someone wants guidance, it\'s because they want guidance.  Not propoganda.

[Levski]

Well, that list merely shows active guilds.  If someone is interested in the guild, he/she will probably investigate it more before coming to a conclusion.

[Valbrandr]

The problem is that it\'s merely a catalogue of guilds with descriptions the guild made about themselves. Each guild will try to reflect on itself in the best possible light, regardless of its reputation in the community.

If someone wants guidance, it\'s because they want guidance. Not propoganda.

What are you talking about?  Going by that logic dont read anyones thread or ask them about their guild because the person will only lie because he/she wants their guild to look better.  In fact dont join a guild because they most likely all liars and doing \"bad\" things behind the scenes.  

Kadas list is the best thing we got.  Most of the guilds are the only guilds in PS that have earned their respect especially the \"Planeshift Guilds of Old\".  So yes it is the best place to look.