Willingly I will answer your questions, Parallo.
Horrid, just horrid. You need more of a line drawn between IC and OOC in my opinion.
This is not a question, it is a statement - if you want me to comment it, please go more into the details and I will be more than willingly to write a re-statement.
What is the thing concerning citizenship and minds all about?
My try of an answer would be the following. I consider this guild more like a 'union'...in terms of a 'party' (not a with the government interacting party for sure) and voice for all of the hard working people. The 'working class'.
Unions are one potential answer for workers at the lower end of the income distribution, but is a return to unions the best solution to the market power imbalance? Should we stay without unions, or should we try to use the political landscape as an opportunity to build better institutions for both workers and firms, institutions that offer workers the same degree of bargaining power that unions provide, and the same degree of income, health, and retirement security, but do so more efficiently? We already know how unions work, pretty much, but can we do even better? I don't know and the time will show, if this system will work out here in this game landscape.
A proposal to implement novel policy has no chance of surviving the political process in a settings like this, even if it is well-grounded in economic fundamentals, and even if it looks to be a clear improvement over unionization for everyone involved. There is the octarchial-governmental llegislation. But why not found a guild for only workers? And this includes the so called 'Citizenship'. I think, an honorable invention and it does not interfer with any terms, that are inside the settings.
To get back to the second part of your question..."and minds all about"...Well. I suppose, that having a mind could be one (but this is now really the only one) requirement to join this guild. I refer to the character for sure. I don't like mindless individuals - in my sense, those aren't individual.
And just that sentance makes my head reel. Seriously.
Well, I shoud have written it down more sensitively. You are completely right, but I wanted to mention the 'use your mules more in an in game sense and interact with them' thing once again. Pardon, if it came too lax...
*edit*
That sounds awful negative, sorry. You just need more reason to make a guild than so that people can have fun with mules. If you make an alt with the intention of not rping with it then fine but all characters should be considered characters as is.
I think, there is enough reason to get together in a working class guild and to fight for members rights and give them a voice. I am not your opinion, sorry, and I also think, that the speech by Ekkdoram is enough reason, explanation and background to interact in a wonderful way here in PlaneShift. Please just relate in future to the speech of Ekkdoram, not my (like I said before) very unsensitive bracket-terms. I should not have written anything in brackets - again a big excuse...I should have let here the pure speech of Ekkdoram. You may be right, if you meant this and relate to this one.
Referring to
That sounds awful negative, sorry
, I cannot say anything, because I have had no chance to read it. Must have been negative then. Why have you written this term then in the *edit* and did not just delete the negative text? Pardon me for not being possible to guess this.
I thank you for your constructive criticism and am willingly to improve the guild's background, but I don't see any suggestions from your side so far.