I wasn't trying to provoke, it's simple:
There are only two commerce guilds active that I have seen in the game.
TTC and the One.
Neither of them interest me (stocks are too complex for my char, and socialism just doesn't ring my bells) but this guild interests me as it has a decent system, isn't an attempt at complete market-monopoly, is neither capitalist or socialist, and is really medieval and I cannot find a part of it that defies settings in any way.
I'm not putting the other guilds down, I'm saying this guild is frankly a better idea (I can't say a better guild yet, as it doesn't exist), and the others should take notice and adapt.