- Status Closed
- Percent Complete
- Task Type Bug Report
- Category Rules → Crafting Transformations
-
Assigned To
Tuathanach - Operating System
- Severity Low
- Priority
- Reported Version
- Due in Version Undecided
-
Due Date
Undecided
-
Votes
1
- Enio Arda (12.02.2014)
- Private
Opened by Enio Arda - 12.02.2014
Last edited by Davide Vescovini - 24.12.2014
FS#6339 - Metallurgy - Melting: Iron/Copper Ingots/Ores no randomized result.
Bug:
1) Melting Iron Ingots results in a fixed (maximum?) amount of quality loss opposed to other metals (i.e. Steel, Gold, Silver) which get a randomized gain/loss.
2) Melting Iron Ore results in no quality loss opposed to other metals (i.e. Steel, Gold, Silver) which get a randomized gain/loss.
Verify:
1) Stack iron ingots to get them to the same quality.
2) Melt them 1 by 1
3) Realize that they all turn out the same decreased quality
4) Redo the same with Gold Ingots and notice these melt to random decreased quality.
Tests done with 130+ Metallurgy Skill and Melted 1 by one after stacking all to same quality.
Iron Ore: q171 all became q171 Molten Iron
Copper ore: q111 all became q111 Molten Copper
Gold Ore: q50 all became random quality, averaged on q101 Molten Gold after Stack (Gain due to low start Q and high Met level?)
Iron Ingot: q143 became q93 Molten Iron
Iron Ingot: q139 became q90 Molten Iron
Most likely a bug located in some mathscripts.
ID | Project | Summary | Priority | Severity | Assigned To | Progress | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2656 | PlaneShift | FS#2656 - list of crafting bugs | Low | Davide Vescovini, Tuathanach |
24.12.2014 23:37
Reason for closing:
Additional comments about closing:
Bug Fixed by Tuathanach.
Troubleshooting hint:
I noticed you can melt Iron Ore (not tested with Copper yet) without having a book in mind.
I believe that is a special case due to the tutorial. You don't get a book in there but need to melt the iron.
I see, then its maybe not related to the reported bug. Thanks.
Maybe it is related. I was once told the standard deviation of the quality fluctuation depends on the crafting book.
Hmm. Maybe those added rules override the book rules then.
Confirmed for Iron and copper ores. Also affects Zinc and tin.
Postponed: pending review of new training system, if new system works as expected then will fix bug.