1: Your guild still doesn't have anything pointing to us as a guild... that im aware of.. so no ic action should really be taken agaisnt us unless you have a firm IC reason for agression non-related to this event.
2: you filed a petition because you got robbed? o.O wow ok... .
Stuff that is valuable to you? small potted plants? some crafted swords, some npc bought swords, a couple of empty sacks, a couple of sacks with daggers in, and a few bits of armor.... Nothing terribly personal in that, nothing that can't be replaced. I'm terribly sorry if you did lose something of emotional value to you, but if you have OOC emotions for an item IG..... detach RL from IG.
A laugh? No
is a smile.. not a laugh..
is a laugh... not
see the difference?
a vendetta against you? no... not really, just saw an open door and thought we'd have a look, if it was my house I'd understandably be annoyed, but mostly with myself for leaving the door open..
No we didn't have an insider, thats OOC and we don't do that, thats against my guild's philosophy and i'd appreciate you not suggesting it. you left your door open, we walked in. Thats it.
The parts about the character in the guildhouse and the npc quotes at the end were intended as a joke... [humor] adding light heartedness to a nasty situation... sorry if you didn't read that from it.
A solution that benefits you? Hmmm well we could stop calling eachother names.. that would benefit us both. If there is something in particular you lost that is IRREPLACEABLE.. I mean you cant get it back, no matter what, and we still have it, I will return it. as i understand what it is to loose something very very special...
Other than that. Theres not really much else other than that, If you want some other sort of recompense, I suggest you take it up with an insurance company, you have insurance don't you?
I also second what Noriin just said and please can we let it rest already, I think we've both made our arguments clear.
also as an afterthought.. remember: even if you are in a little fantasy world, someone can always burst your bubble of perfection. Good guys DONT ALWAYS WIN