I'd like to point out that it isnt JUST IZZABELLA.. I posted this thread and I am responsible as well, so please don't direct all your abuse to her.
1. Do you intend to return our stuff?
Nope, we sold it already
Well, then we don't really have anything to discuss ... You have an entire guild on your backs now ... and i kinda have a feeling that we got a few supporters in other guilds too.
2. Why did you wait at least 33 hours to inform us that you were doing a RP and we don't really have any option than to accept and follow the rules you have set?
I think you realized the moment one of you tried to get into the guild hall and warning you would really have ruined our stealth don't you think?
Well, I think there is a reason why we filed a petition: Nobody had a clue of what was going on. You could at least have written in the note [this is a RP: for any further details contact: XYZ. But please note that XYZ do not participate in this event as an actor just as a supervisor]
3. You don't considering involving us in a RP like that without even asking one of us and set up a set of rules is god modding?
Setting up rules for robbing.. thats a contradiction already. Theres not really a way to make a theft "fair".. and theres also no way of planning you leaving your door open.... go figure.
Did you even consider the possibility that we might actully like such an event if we had a clue?
Yes, Im telling you: You should have contacted one of our Tamers. Ask him to act as a supervisor just so we know what was going on and what to expect.
I don't really need many rules for such an event except for one: People will get the stuff back that matters to them.
4. How can you claim we left our door open when we know it might as well be a bug? We instructs the members that have a kety for the GH carefully how to enter the house you know.
Obviously one of your members forgot to lock it as every other house is locked and has been locked since that time. Also, when you lock your own house don't you check its locked properly?
Oh well, this is not pretty anymore so i might aswell write this:
Since you are so certain about this I can only guess on you had an insider that have gotten a key somehow.
5. Do you think we find loosing all our stuff in the GH fun without knowing why it is gone and having no chance of knowing who did it?
No I shouldn't think it was terribly fun for you but being robbed is never fun. It is gone because you left the door open and we did it. <<still ooc btw 
I don't understand the smiley there. You are ruining the pleasure for a lot of people with playing PS and you find it funny?
This is a game pal. Its supposed to be funny FOR EVERYBODY.
6. wouldn't it have been possible to do this just by taking our furniture or some other unimportant stuff and leaving a note saying you have been robbed instead of ripping us completely taking stuff that there was a purpose why it was there?
As I mentioned before thieves don't take your underwear they take your TV, thats completely illogical
So thieves steal all furniture plants and everything else of absolutely no value? NO
This looks more like a vandetta against a guild than an actual fun RP event.
7. Do you intend to leave us clues somewhere so we have a chance of tracking you down (IC)?
We have left lots of clues but you obviously haven't seen them so what more can we do?
We had absolutely no idea if we should look for clues.
8, will you be willing to negotiate a set of rules for this that alters the way you have acted so far?
Like what? we return your stuff and surrender to the town guard suffering a permadeath? or prewarn you in advance next time so you can say no?
Well, At least return the stuff that matters to people. Stuff thats not easily replaceable. But I guess you didn't think that far as this would actually affect a lot of people alot.
9. did you consider that this might actually course a lot more harm than fun?
It's a robbery, it isn't fun. Next time will break into your guild house and tidy it up and maybe leave some nice things for you.
ITS a game. But if you like it that way I am now (or at least my alt is) an assassin looking out for "random" people to kill ... is that fun? Tell me if its fun when you have been killed 10 times in a day when you just want to mine platinum. Yea, it might seem meaning less to you, but its great fun for me ... so i guess its ok.
10. why did you not contact at least one of our members before you did this? That would have helped a lot on how we feel about this
See question number 2
You still don't get it do you?
11. Did you leave chars in our GH which could steel even more stuff from us?
No, we left after cleaning you out I think, but you'll never know will you?
If you did, that highly OOC and will definitely get reported and expected to taken action upon. There is absolutely no way you would be able to hide in there IC.
12. How did you manage to steal everything when there were around 100 Elemental Light members sleeping in there and a few others which have been granted access?
100 people in your guildhouse? do you sleep on the windowsill? Pretty cosy I would imagine 
You didn't answer the question. Or did you not think that was possible?
13. How can you say for sure that the NPC outside our door didn't otice anything oh and also the NPC at the entrance into the Plaza?
After the event I asked Fholen Medraa about it and he said:
Fholen Medraa says: I don't understand. Can you rephrase?
Sov says: about robbery
Fholen Medraa says: I don't understand. Can you rephrase?
Sov says: about thieves
Fholen Medraa says: I don't understand. Can you rephrase?
Sov says: about guild house
Fholen Medraa says: I don't understand. Can you rephrase?
So I think that about covers all your questions. Please let me know if you have more...
Oh yea, thats RP at its best ... i see that ... NOT
Thats just taking advantage of game mechanics again.
Find a reasonable solution to this OOC quick, one that benefits us.
- Kiaerulf
Ulber Tamer of Elemental Light
[/quote]
