I had hoped that the outrage over this wouldn't have gotten so big and so public in so short a time. As it stands, I feel I have to step up and explain a few things about what happened prior to the auction.
While it is true that the idea for it and the announcement about the auction in the forums have been around for almost a month, I must point out that ONE of the GM's did approach me and discuss this situation a few days ago. I won't post the log as that is not allowed, but what I took away from that discussion was that the GM's had met and discussed introducing this new resolution. I was under the understanding that:
- Our advertising before the auction should be done in the /auction channel, rather than in /shout, as we had been doing.
- Bidding in the /auction channel was acceptable, as long as it was kept In Character but that it was slightly frowned upon.
- The test auctions that both Proglin and I ran at separate times appeared to have a bit too much chatter in the /auction channel
I approached Proglin about this and we discussed taking the bidding out of the /auction channel. As we had not been told specifically NOT to do it, we decided that, not only was it easier for us as the auctioneers to keep track of the bidding when it is done in a different colour chat, it seemed to us at the time that it was adding to the RP atmosphere of the event, not detracting from it. Thus, we decided to keep it the way we had originally planned it.
Being forced to take the auction entirely into /say (We were told by the GM at the event to take it to /group or /tell - How is one supposed to foster an RP atmosphere by taking the RP into /group or /tell where no bystanders can see it and join in?), totally changed the mood and atmosphere of the event. To try and keep the auctioneer sane enough to keep track of bids, we had to ask all the people there to limit their /say chatter. This essentially killed the mood, and prevented (in my opinion anyway) many from expanding on the RP and playing their roles properly. Some tried and a big THANKS go out to you for trying to make the event even better than it was. Proglin and I would like to sincerely apologize to Anfa, as because of the unexpected changes, one or more of her bids got lost because of range issues and she lost out on getting a particular item she had her eye on, even though it was clearly within her means to pay more.
To sum up, part of the blame for this fiasco rests solely on my shoulders, but I am in no way defending the actions of the GM who intervened, as I feel it could have been handled much better. Hopefully the outcome of this will be a better system to help promote RP events like this, instead of suppress them, which is what I feel happened here. From the few latter posts in the thread I feel things are headed in the right direction.
Bod