I would hope that every single person in the game does whatever he/she does in the game from an OOC perspective.
Try as I might, I cant understand this sentence- could you rephrase it?
I don\'t expect everyone to sit around and chat all day, doing nothing; that would be out of character for most of them. However, I do expect people to create some frame of character and stick to that frame. The creation of the guild should fall within this frame and be supported by it as well.
Well, I\'d argue that there\'s a difference between \"Creating a Frame\" and engaging in roleplay. In my mind, people expect you to not break the roleplay atmosphere- However very few people
expect you to activly engage in roleplay. I think theres 3 different levels- OOC, Passive RP and Active RP. OOC obviously either referring to the game itself or talking about real life events. Passive Roleplay means just acting as if you were in game- Talking to people, asking people questions, killing stuff, etc. Active Roleplay would be strictly sticking to medievil talk and character, and/or engaging in roleplaying activites and the like. I think It is expected that you maintain Passive Roleplay, so you dont ruin it for others- But I havent, in game, seen much expectation that you conform to the higher level. Perhaps its meant to be different?, but it isnt at the moment.
It can be completely dueling as long as this is in-character
Agreed. Additionally, Making it not all dueling doesnt make up for the lack of depth in terms of story etc,.