Volund / Sallorile Disputed Match - Official Decision
NOTE: To avoid this in future, please make sure you have both given a clear indication in group-chat (or where ever it can be witnessed) that the fight you are about to have is the official one. There was no clear agreement between both parties in this dispute immediately prior to the fight, which has of course complicated the issues leading to my decision.
Okay, it was an awkward decision but I've made it anyway:
It was certainly implied to Sallorile by Volund that Volund was wanting only official matches (to save on degrading his weapon quality) ("no rematches", etc.) ... and it appeared Volund was refusing to fight Sallorile unless it was the official fight... even to the point he asked in group if anyone was up for an official duel instead of fighting Sallorile.
They then had the fight.
Immediately after this, Sallorile stated "i have officaly dueled you in the YWL"... and Volund responded "and you lost".
With this being a dispute... AND because there are no witnesses to it directly [and because I didn't see it stated CLEARLY that it was the official duel they were about to have... I have decided:
To Volund & Sallorile:
You can fight two duels in addition to the one already fought... and make it best of 3.
That means, Sallorile, that you will need to beat Volund twice in a row, to take the win. I know it's hard work for you, but from the chat-log it appears you admitted to officially fighting Volund.
If these two matches aren't fought, the win will be given to Volund based on the evidence in the group-chat log.
That is my decision, it's the official decision, I hope you find it fair.
(and I checked to see if Sallorile may have said about the official duel in response to someone else... but there's no evidence of that!!!)
(01:40:52)
(01:41:51) Volund tells group: there are no rematches, I want to duel everyone else
(01:42:04) Sallorile tells group: who says this is a rematch
(01:42:16) Volund tells group: I still aint wasting my quality
(01:42:31) Sallorile tells group: cause you cant afford it
(01:43:08) Volund tells group: I have 7 SW ss
(01:43:19) Volund tells group: and 1 million 3 hundred thousand
(01:43:30) Volund tells group: I can, but dont want to bro
(01:43:31) Sallorile tells group: lol noi wounder i lost i still have my ruined dagger and weapon repir kit on
(01:43:46) Volund tells group: You had 2 daggers on
(01:44:03) Volund tells group: and you didnt get a hit on me so doesnt really matter
(01:44:37) Sallorile tells group: are you scared you will loose to me?
(01:44:43) Volund tells group: taunting wont work
(01:44:46) Sallorile tells group: then why wont you duel
(01:45:03) Sallorile tells group: its not like you will loose anything if you die or win?
(01:45:08) Volund tells group: No
(01:45:59) Volund tells group: anyone comin to DR for officla match duel
--- the fight takes place here ---
(01:46:16) Sallorile tells group: i have officaly dueled you in the YWL
(01:47:59) Volund tells group: and you lost
(01:48:16) Sallorile tells group: cebot you want your ruined dagger back?
(01:48:18) Volund tells group: Now I need to duel cebot and ecuetas for now
(01:48:35) Sallorile tells group: that wasnt an offical duel you hadnt mentioned it yet