Planeshift is intended to be a roleplaying game, even if some players don't RP. If there are two "creeds", RPing is no longer the norm, and that would ruin RP for quite a few people, in my opinion. PLs do mostly still respect RP, and even to RP, people DO have to be realistic with their characters' stats- I'm not going to RP a great duelist if in reality I can't even pick up a sword

Keep the balance... (Sorry for the stereotypical phrase- if anyone can think of something more imaginative...)