my 2 tria...
If the description has details I would see normally, but more information than is currently implemented, then i vote YES*
*I find that a lot of the descrptions are walking sandwich boards with life stories on them. Once I get to the first bit of info I would not be able to "SEE" then I stop reading.
Regarding the linked thread, I think discussing your armor can be easily done. Um, people can see which armor you have on. so, the fact I am wearing a clacker claw on a red twine necklace, sure, but WHY I am wearing it... nope.
Under that criteria, I have not found much need to remember all the details of people I run into. Especially since I find people tend to live at one extreme or the other, either no descriptions, or a novella.
BTW, last I checked, the only books you could save as a text file anymore are the ones you authored. I also used to have a couple books saved for notes, about people (npcs mainly) and quests, that Bamko could refer to whenever he needed to.