Author Topic: Get out there and RP more!  (Read 17477 times)

Lhaa

  • Guest
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #30 on: May 03, 2010, 10:33:24 am »
@Lhaa: You know very little of my interactions with XilliX, or Talad for that matter. It's rather unwise to suggest I am ignorant in the matters concerning politics in PlaneShift development. Whether or not Talad benefits personally from my contribution is not the reason I contribute as a prospect, I contribute for the community.

I suggested nothing else than what I can tell is right, whether it is what you understood or not, and I'm not going to waste more words detailing it or contradicting you so we'll never know.
But you're in the wrong place if you want to contribute to the community (I gently remind you the thread's name and prompt you to do it). Every person who stops RPing to do game content that hardly ever gets out there or becomes a quest to feed PLers' hunger of trinkets is doing harm to the community. Every GM that was once a good RPer is a loss for the community because of the way things are done (read Aiw's post again if you forgot), not because a GM can't be a good RPer or vice versa, this works pretty fine elsewhere as a matter of fact. I know you haven't had time to see this by yourself yet and even less ponder whatever I say (heck, I've tried to warn much smarter people and failed only to be given the point some moths later lol), but in due time, after your tongue slips out of where it is now, you will figure out. Too bad the time will already be wasted, and you'll probably be as burnt up as those who left before you for the same reasons and never or rarely got back IG. But if you get back to RPing often post your mighty RPs in the forum, I'm sure they'll be welcome. And maybe then I would give you a point, if I could see that. For now you're just the next marionette, no matter your reasons to accept that role. I guess that makes you a good roleplayer. ;)
Now, I'm not in the mood to read more of your BS and I guess the OP isn't either so don't reply to this. Thanks.


Now that, we've gotten through yet another round of back and forth, let's please stick to positive threads like Dracaeon's.

Sorry for hijacking your thread Illysia, you're one of the few people that didn't deserve it. Didn't plan to get back to it after you asked, but some things can't be left unanswered.
I'm off now.

Candy

  • Hydlaa Notable
  • *
  • Posts: 962
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #31 on: May 03, 2010, 10:51:26 am »
This is addressed to everyone; I'm just piggybacking on Kaerli's post.

There are several problems I see with RP:

1) noobs don't get the indoctrination in RP they used to.  This is an area the tutorial tries to help out with with Xargon, but it seems that not many folk want to listen to his lecture...:P  That, and quite a few newbies are still getting dragged off into non-RP guilds (*cough* Nexus of Devotion *hack* just an example :P)--

Oi! I tried. I might have kinda sorta broken the guild a little doing it, but I tried.
Quote
--Us folk running RP guilds (Rangers, RHoP, Outlaws Guild, House of Treyus, etal) kind of need to step up our efforts not just to recruit newbies, but to give them a proper edification when it comes to roleplaying.

Who says guilds need to do it? I mean, sure, it's great to have a guild that teaches you how to (role)play. Individuals should do this, too. Perhaps we should have an OOC primer on roleplay that gets passed to each new toon on the RP server in case they don't find those of us that have the patience for newbies, though.

Quote
3) The newbies tend to be afraid to try to RP, most of this I'll chalk up to stage fright :P but we do need to find a better way to bring people up to speed on game settings.  Using quests to disseminate settings information is simply ineffective.  Why? To find out which quests your character should run, you either have to ask characters in a similar profession (sometimes easier said than done), rely on OOC spoilers (:( ), or run every quest in the game (which is too time consuming).  The books provide references for some matters, but much of that information is hard to find for the average player (its better than information buried in quests though), and it's kind of hard to run to Jayose's (or worse, the DR citadel) every time a mundane Settings question pops up mid-roleplay.  What we really need is a "quick reference guide" that contains most of the Settings things that a roleplayer would need, in a format that we can keep HANDY and easily distribute to noobs.

THIS. A thousand times this. I want to know why x race does/wears/eats y thing, but do I really have to harvest small animals for their body parts and run six round trips around the Dome to find out? Honestly? Can't we just have more library books (maybe implement some system where we can actually borrow them and pass them around so that not everyone has to either scribe it or /die to read something?), NPCs that know things when you chat with them, item/NPC descriptions with potentially useful nuggets of information embedded in them, et cetera?

Also, an afterthought on channels - First off, we need a clear indicator that they're OOC (although, if done right, IC channels could work. I've seen some pretty good ones in that other game). We shouldn't autojoin gossip by default, as has probably been said before. I'm of the opinion that there should be an option to join channels, if one clicks the tab, and then a list of different ones like a channel for RP Connections (when you can't find where everyone's run off to), Settings help, that kind of thing. Maybe a specific one for newbies, too.
Role Play Preferences
Quote
[1: gossip] Glaciusor: There's now a guy in skimpy armor having war flashbacks about daemons. Have fun Hydlaa

Akkaido Kivikar

  • Hydlaa Notable
  • *
  • Posts: 726
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #32 on: May 03, 2010, 12:00:04 pm »
Only, nobody pulls my strings on the devteam. I work on whatever I choose. Apart from one time during the pre-release phase when weltall needed my help fixing Action Locations so all your guildhouse doors, map labels, forges, furnaces, etc. worked.

I don't see what I have done as wasted effort, I have had a fair amount of fun, myself and my Blender program. The contributions I have made should benefit RPer and PLer, a fit contribution for both servers. I hardly see how expanding the game area, especially in adding and designing areas with potential roleplay use in mind, is a waste of time.

Aiwendil

  • Guest
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #33 on: May 03, 2010, 05:38:02 pm »
Just got back from hospital
Glad to hear this Lolitra.

Quote from: Aiwendil
Obviously it failed epically.
The RCO failed simply because nobody cared. Well, they did, at least enough to say they do, then mostly do nothing about it. Very few people were up to help us and to be honest, we shouldn't be surprised about that. It's much easier to sit and wait for others to give you the fun than providing it yourself, even if it's not so fun for you then. In the end it was our mistake to believe something as big could be done in PS. If simple PL guilds fail all the time (let alone RP ones...), something like the RCO with its structure and needs was meant to fail from the start.
Yes, I know...it was started far too late and it should have been clear from the start that it will fail. I'm just can't fight the optimist in me sometimes. So let's put it in the same category of stupid things I tried as the joining the GM team...okay?

(and the quality varying wildly from good RP to epic tavern fights where everyone has inexplicably glowing body parts and lorebreaking spells and abilities - when I've been on it's been so deloate, RP-wise, that I even miss those. Ugh.)
Not so sure about that...having to carry Lhaa around the whole time because her second leg got broken also would have been hard. ;)

Lhaa, if you keep it up. I'm going to give you a sign that says "I'm n ur thredz, stealin ur happyz." or one that say "I haz a grumpy."  :P you too Aiwendil.
Awww, can I still have that sign even now after stopping playing PS? I like that...goes and changes his signature

The community is the lifeblood of the game - the mechanics are merely the body. Ones the blood drains out the body is dead.
With the community dead it might as well be a solo rpg.

You want rp to be alive? You need a lot of people who give a crap - not just one or two rp-saviors.

You want rp back ?
Do what it takes to attract and retain solid players.

If need be, get rid of the sucky players - kick them off for not role playing, tell them they must change, or take away the game mechanics. ( Take down the npc's for good )

That's harsh, I know.
Its worth considering though.

The resulting question is, how important is it to have a role playing community?

As it stands there are a fist full of players left scattered accors multiple timezones on a very large map.
the coals need to be lumped together somehow before the fire goes out.
Agreeing to almost everything here...and it might even be a good time for that seeing that I was flamed down in the past for saying something similar in even more nice words. Seems with the current lack of RP and players this is more likely to be accepted. Just far too late.

I love these topics because they always come about at regular intervals.
I know.

Finally, Aiwendil, I'm just amazed at your patience explaining what we already said so many times and never managed to get through. Too bad I can't feel like spending so much time in it. At least in this side it feels like it's already too late. Whether it is too late for me or the whole community is something I wouldn't dare answer to. But my posts will have to do with shorter, pungent words most of the time. o/
And if the people who run the game won't listen to your suggestions at all, don't play anymore. It won't change. If they do, good for you, get your ideas out there and your opinion heard. Talk to Talad, see what he says. If he doesn't listen or straight-up says no, you know that this game probably isn't for you.
...
I have not been playing because I don't have an interest in logging in. Loading is too much for me, I get tired looking at that screen. RP sucks, it is blatantly terrible. The bugs and lag and crashing I can handle, as long as the content of the game is good. It's not. So it adds onto the pile of dung that is what I see in the game right now. You don't like what I'm saying? Too bad. Because a hell of alot of people feel this exact same way.
All I'm saying is that RP isn't dead, we all just need to try something new.
I lost all my patience by now Lhaa. Not going to try to make any more suggestions, run any more events in game or even login. For me it's for sure far too late...not going to take any of this crap any longer. So I take Dracaeon's suggestion and do something new...playing another game that actually is fun as it is meant to be and not annoying almost all of the time. To all remaining I wish that their over and over repeated mantra "There is nothing wrong with PS" will help them to actually believe it themselves sometime. On a side note...thx for the post Kull, I have to admit that it actually felt good to read it.

@Lhaa: You know very little of my interactions with XilliX, or Talad for that matter. It's rather unwise to suggest I am ignorant in the matters concerning politics in PlaneShift development. Whether or not Talad benefits personally from my contribution is not the reason I contribute as a prospect, I contribute for the community.

@Aiwendil: I did not specifically claim to be doing anything to help RP, in my last post... I meant the game community as a whole. The only thing I can do to help RP in PlaneShift, in my honest opinion is to spend more time ingame RPing. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
The question is for what community...Not much of a community left I would say. You help the game, nothing else. The PS team can keep on imagining they do it for the community as much as they like, it won't come more true. The truth is that they make the game they want. They don't listen to the community at all. I am not saying that this is wrong...creating a game can be fun itself and give one a satisfying feeling about having created something. It's their good right to make it as they want as they are the ones doing the work. But calling it work for the community is just plain ignorant. For the PS team the so called community is nothing else than second class testers that are exchangeable whenever needed.

And sorry for the misunderstanding, must have happened because the thread is about roleplaying, but doesn't really change anything on my points there...they are still valid.

I hardly see how expanding the game area, especially in adding and designing areas with potential roleplay use in mind, is a waste of time.
And this is what you obviously don't understand. This thread is about roleplaying not improving the game in general. The game has already a lot things that could be used for roleplaying but aren't. Adding more of such things might for sure be good for the game but doesn't help the current RP situation at all. Sure, let's add a new map to the game so that the 40 players online are scattered even more in Ylikaum. Nah, wait, even better...created some more monsters and place them all over the map so that there are enough monsters of every kind enabling all players at the same time to hit an ulbernaut. Or how about rejecting RP rules because they would be a PR disaster and drive off all the PLers from the server...that's how the team is going about RP. But I am repeating myself...you are right Lhaa...I am too patient.

And please let me address all those who rant about Sarras. Not too long ago Sarras was talking like you all, so maybe take it as a chance for an lookout to your own future. Sorry, Sarras, couldn't resist.

So let me try to be a bit positive:
I really hope the game stay fun for all those keeping playing it. Furthermore I hope that the issues some of those see can be solved in a way that is acceptable for all. I already agreed with Illysia, at least if you can "look past my anger", that the best way to improve the situation is going out there and start some roleplay. I'm just too "tired" of all the crap going on in and around PS to do it myself anymore. So farewell to all those remaining..I really hope you find in PS what you are looking for.

Illysia

  • Forum Addict
  • *
  • Posts: 2774
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #34 on: May 03, 2010, 08:36:27 pm »
@Sarras: It's not being disingenuous, what I mean might have just gone over your head, and I did nothing to your point. More than likely the point you were making just wasn't strong enough on it's own.

@LigH: Sorry I missed you, but I log on when I can and it is kinda sporadic right now. Once finals are over, it should be better.

@Roled: Thank you for that post Roled. That is the kind of thing this thread is for, and as for parties, it will have to be after this week as this is finals week.  :o

@Lhaa: Thank you Lhaa.  :)
Sorry for hijacking your thread Illysia, you're one of the few people that didn't deserve it. Didn't plan to get back to it after you asked, but some things can't be left unanswered.
I'm off now.

@Aiwendil: Thank you for the positive part of your post.
So let me try to be a bit positive:
I really hope the game stay fun for all those keeping playing it. Furthermore I hope that the issues some of those see can be solved in a way that is acceptable for all. I already agreed with Illysia, at least if you can "look past my anger", that the best way to improve the situation is going out there and start some roleplay. I'm just too "tired" of all the crap going on in and around PS to do it myself anymore. So farewell to all those remaining..I really hope you find in PS what you are looking for.



Now all of the debate out of the way. I'd like to make a general call to oldbies to come back and pick up their old RPs. PS is in an upswing for RP and most of "N00bz" have left the game as well. Now is a good time to pick up where you left off and maybe even develop some new twists in some old stories. Side note: if you happen to have been in RPs with my characters in times long past, I am especially calling you out.  ;D


Added Later:

Well, this must be doing some good as here I am sitting in the tavern during the afternoon(American) and not only are there people in the tavern, there is RP going on. And not just two people talking, it's several people holding little conversations.  \\o// This is the time to revive RP. No more naysaying, get out there and RP!  :thumbup:
« Last Edit: May 03, 2010, 11:23:25 pm by Illysia »

bloodedIrishman

  • Guest
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #35 on: May 04, 2010, 06:01:55 am »
What's with people using different accounts on the forum? And using more than one on the same topic? Now come on.

Quote
and there is not need for pessimism.

This is true. But don't mistake good criticism for pessimism either.

And it's spelled NO.




LigH

  • Forum Legend
  • *
  • Posts: 7096
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #36 on: May 04, 2010, 08:21:37 am »
@ Aiwendil & Lhaa:

I hope you don't complain that I am unable to fix the HoM objects in the RCD... apart from that I wonder who you mean with "not enough support", or how much would be enough; but as much in game as in real life, there are people who are able, and people who are available, and they are not always the same. After all, it is not our job, it is just a game ... I am ready to spend a lot of efforts, but real life issues still have priority.

Gag Harmond
Knight and Ambassador
The Royal House of Purrty

Akkaido Kivikar

  • Hydlaa Notable
  • *
  • Posts: 726
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #37 on: May 04, 2010, 08:30:22 am »
I still don't see how creating more things for the game is a waste of time, when it will benefit all players, which includes the RPers.

I've been ingame a few times over the past few days, and have a few small RPs. Personally I prefer them over the RPer run events, because characters tend to show through and shine more in a small RP, rather than large events where it gets lost in the mess of conversation.

Though I do appreciate big RPs too, don't get me wrong there. :)

LigH

  • Forum Legend
  • *
  • Posts: 7096
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #38 on: May 04, 2010, 09:05:56 am »
Helping to create new things is not wrong.

It is just unfortunate to see often how new Developers and Game Masters tend to play less in-game. Recently e.g. I poked Addeline to return as cooking teacher, and warned Haraun not to leave the Lair alone... ;)

Gag Harmond
Knight and Ambassador
The Royal House of Purrty

Akkaido Kivikar

  • Hydlaa Notable
  • *
  • Posts: 726
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #39 on: May 04, 2010, 10:16:05 am »
Well, what do you expect, it's not like we suddenly have more time than before to develop and play the game. And development of the game is at least of minor importance, otherwise there will never be a Klyros city, a finished Ojaveda, homes for all races and characters.

Vakachehk

  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1468
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #40 on: May 04, 2010, 10:19:10 am »
Well I haven't been on much either, but I have something installed for everyone which will be a benefit to every RPer and PLer :)
You maybe roleplaying but you could still be OOC.

Happy

  • Traveller
  • *
  • Posts: 17
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #41 on: May 04, 2010, 08:13:11 pm »
Such a debate here! My goodness. Anyway no offense to the op but has anyone ever defined what role play is? In the nameless game I play, I would not want any of you to join it and ruin it, there are no arguments about role play, it comes naturally and it is fun. It is part of the game as much as leveling or questing. In some cases we even level up because of a great role play.

Once a great while I come to see this forum and I am amazed at how horrible it is. My gaming community is kind, helpful and a great deal of fun. Ever think the forum keeps new people from playing? If so maybe, just maybe all of you need to put on a new face to attract more people to this game.

I only feel sorry for the founder of this game because he had an idea so people could have fun and now, and what seems like for years past, he has watched players be so mean and nasty and ruin his vision of fun for many.

Rigwyn

  • Guest
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #42 on: May 04, 2010, 08:25:56 pm »
Have you ever played this game before Happy ?
Why not try it out ? Its free.

Sign on and try role playing with the current PS community.
You just might like it.


garoninja

  • Hydlaa Resident
  • *
  • Posts: 130
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #43 on: May 04, 2010, 08:37:04 pm »
>.> Must it be emphasized that this a GAME.....*mutters something about more politics that game play*

Quote
Garosan grins "Sit on me and I'll put a crossbow bolt in the back of your head then bludgeon Vayl to death with one of your arms."

verden

  • Hydlaa Notable
  • *
  • Posts: 716
    • View Profile
Re: Get out there and RP more!
« Reply #44 on: May 04, 2010, 08:50:26 pm »
Everyone has tried to define it countless times. The problem is all games with roleplay mechanics rely on a moderator to interpret and enforce scenarios on the players. In PS (and WoW, et cetera) the role of game moderator is entirely different. It is left to the players to enforce roleplay on each other and on themselves. Tsk.