I like it when people say it becomes less fantasy, but lets get a rough definition of fantasy.
Fantasy: Fiction characterized by highly fanciful or supernatural elements; a capricious or fantastic idea; a conceit
Science Fiction: A literary or cinematic genre in which fantasy, typically based on speculative scientific discoveries or developments, environmental changes, space travel, or life on other planets, forms part of the plot or background.
Even though science fiction is based on speculative scientific discoveries, Planeshift does have its share of science. Planeshift is basically life on another planet so therefore Planeshift is Fantasy/Scifi. As for space travel, well there are portals, maybe they\'re wormholes so it could be traveling through space. Plus Yliakum itself is geological science, studying it, on the settings page.
So how would this game become less of a fantasy if gas harvesting were added? Newpie you believe that an MMORPG only has to have mining, well it doesn\'t. We\'ve all grown to accustomed to \"just\" mining, me included. But Planeshift is about like you said, fantasy. By not even giving this idea a thought and just saying it doesn\'t make it a fantasy game anymore is already breaking the definition of fantasy itself. Actually I\'m not saying it will happen but if this were implemented it\'d make it even more fantasy because of the raw definition of fantasy.
But then there\'s always some dude saying (not saying that its you Newpie) that there\'s a difference between the \"fantasy setting,\" and the \"definition of fantasy.\"
How the heck are they different? The fantasy setting is the samething as the definition of fantasy. Without the definition of fantasy, how would you know what a fantasy setting is?
Oh sure, 2 handed swords, armor, assassins, potions, I mean some dudes will complain that that\'s lame and boring. Every MMORPG, level up, fight, get money, every single time. But what Planeshift does is not follow that. That\'s what makes it unique.
Okay what if we took the world of Planeshift. And changed it to like:
- Yliakum is a world, not a underground cavern thing.
- Pteosaurs are horses
- All the money is now called gold
- Only thing jobs are mining, smithing, fishing, cooking
- There\'s only humans, elves, and dwarfs
- Only weapons are swords and arrows
I\'m might get flamed for this but I\'ll take a stand. But there are some people who want to morph Planeshift into that type of game. You can tell by the people who don\'t take into new ideas.
I mean what if Planeshift Head Dude Luca Pancallo and the other Devs didn\'t want Yliakum to be underground or the only monster\'s are orcs and goblins. Think how unoriginal the game would\'ve been.
Honestly, I didn\'t post this to offend anyone or make anyone made but I just wanted to say that sometimes we as people have to try to think out of the box a little more.
EDIT: Sorry I got off topic anyways.