40
« on: November 07, 2008, 05:02:37 am »
I did a search for "atheism" covering the last 400 days of the forum. This topic has been discussed, but I don't think it's been discussed the way I'm going to discuss it, so I feel comfortable making this thread.
I'm approaching this topic from a place of ignorance. I don't know the plan of the settings team and I haven't been involved in the discussions about religion and the settings at that level.
I made a new character today and the description of Atheists raised some questions for me. I'm not sure I know what Atheism is anymore in the context of Planeshift, or how it's viewed.
Despite the obvious presence of Gods and Goddesses throughout Yliakum, some deny that these beings are worthy of worship.
This is the line that has me confused. In discussions, we've always distinguished between two senses of Atheist: One, someone who denies the existence of the gods. Two, someone who denies that the gods are worthy of worship. Two very different senses.
My understanding was that the consensus was that the first sense, the sense closest to the real life definition of Atheist, is absurd in Yliakum. First off, the definition of "god" may be synonymous with "infinately powerful wizard". But secondly, people in Yliakum recognize the existence of the gods because people in Yliakum recognize the existence of the gods. It's a cultural thing. An outside observer, while they might find it right or wrong, would see this if they looked at Yliakum. Everyone recognizes the existence of the gods. This is ok because of the flexible definition of "god" and because the influence of the gods is so pervasive in Yliakum society. In our own world, there was a time in Europe when pretty much everyone believed in God, and there was far less evidence.
My confusion here is because the line I quoted in bold and italics mixes the senses. "Despite the obvious... some deny that these beings are worthy of worship." This is clearly a reference to the second sense of Atheist: That sense that says that the character recognizes the gods exist, but does not see the gods as worthy of worship.
So I'm confused. In every discussion I've had up until now, we've treated the two senses of Atheist as very different things. One was always completely unacceptable, and the other was tolerable (and perhaps even relatively common). The quote I took from the character generator seems to be in exact opposition to that.
I'm hoping that someone can help me to better understand what's going on, and how I could misunderstand things so completely.
The rest of the information on Atheism:
Most people consider atheists foolish at best and a condemned object of pity at worst.
This makes sense for characters who deny the gods exist. I'm not sure how this should work for characters who don't think the gods should be worshipped. Is this another one of those cultural things, that is simply true because it is true?
Athests will bear the worst effects of the penalty for dying since no god will grant them succor from it.
This seems logical.
The atheist does not look outside itself for truth.
This confuses me. Can someone explain what the author meant by "look outside itself"? Is "itself" a typo? It should be themself. Also, why is this so prescriptive for the character's reasoning (or lack of reasoning)? Or am I reading too much into it?
People attracted to this faith: People who have had a bad experience with religion, anti-social people, staunch individualists, and the irrational.
Again, I find this highly prescriptive for the character's motivation in being an Atheist, and frankly I'm not sure where it's coming from. What's the rational basis for this part of the settings? In Yliakum, do anti-social, individualist, and irrational have the same meanings that they do in the real world? Why should these qualities be especially applied to characters who are Atheist, and applied to all characters who are Atheist? (By "Why", I mean "How does this serve the game?")
I'm hoping that this post doesn't offend anyone's work. If it seems like I'm being critical, I'm merely expressing confusion on a topic I know little about. Understanding this issue better will help me (and possibly others) become better roleplayers.