Originally posted by fken
3) (the most interesting!) @Seytra: another extremist point of view: you are forcig people to think like you.
First of all this is the second tiome you speak of my views as being \"extremist\" while they in fact are moderate. I see nothing extremist with what I posted on this topic, so I must assume that since you dislike what I said you try to label it \"extremist\" in order to discourage people to agree with it.
Originally posted by fken
THE ONLY Interesting argument would be to say something like too many guild is polluting server memory... but it\'s the only argument you didnt wrote.
Because it has been stated several times that memory isn\'t an issue ATM.
Originally posted by fken
If I read what you said I am wondering if you arent simply jealous of others way of life because they are able to do what they wanna do and you not.
I can only laugh at that.
Originally posted by fken
What\'s the problem when you see people creating a future dead guild? This guild will stop alone.
Well, the problem is (or should be) obvious: they make guilds look like a matter of having an additional line of text under the chars name. A guild is serious business, and they are diluting it\'s importance. A guild is more than a random bunch of people. Just like IRL, you don\'t just meet a few friends and call yourself a guild, or anything beyond friends.
Originally posted by fken
But in fact you wanna show newbees that you are someone important and they arent... it\'s the only reason I am understanding in your argumentation.
Well, it is quite obvious that you have no idea what I am talking about.
Originally posted by fken
By the way I must admit I thought like you that it was a problem all these guys who create guilds without following the rules but... I understood there are things more important than this fact and really... it was stupid...
Did I ever say that it is the most important thing? No, because it isn\'t. However, you cannot only care about the most important things, because otherwise the less important things become hell eventually.
Originally posted by fken
You said it was realistic to pay a fees for belonging to a guild...
First it\'s wrong because in middleage people groups them only in regards with their ideas
Were these guilds? No, they were not. A guild is an organization that aims to protect and dominate a sector of economy. They also provide financial and other services, so they require money or other fees from their members.
Originally posted by fken
Then, I belong to the Debian community and I never paid fees for it... so it\'s still possible today...
And that proves exactly what? Debian is a nonprofit organization, so they are not required to pay taxes and such. Also, they do still need donations. I honestly don\'t think Debian compares to a guild.