I remember being new. It seems to me I was embraced by the players pretty quickly and felt like a ‘member of the family.’ Somehow that has been lost and I do not know if it this new generation of players or not. One thing I did not like was each time I met a player I was asked, ‘Do you want to join my guild?’ In order to keep the new players the older players must try to remember what it was like when they started. For me it was how I was so welcomed. Maybe for someone else it would be how they received the help they needed. Or maybe it was just the way people ignored them and with sheer determination they succeeded in understanding the game play anyway.
I think a newbie guild is not going to work because it puts people together in one place and gives them a title, ‘New.’ That can cause embarrassment. My suggestion is to have players volunteer to help the new player that looks lost. ‘Hello, my name is ______, can I help you with anything this fine day?’ Not only will you be helping someone, but also I am pretty sure you might even learn something new yourself. Even if it is how to better help the new player the next time. One piece of advice I received from Grroow was to stay on the ‘well traveled paths’ and that helped me a lot in the beginning. So you never know what you might say to help or hinder the new player so I say that you should tread carefully.
Another suggestion is the books. It would be great to have books that better explain how to do things without giving all the information out so they still have to work it out their selves. I would love to see books written about the players themselves that can also have little hints in them as to how something can be done, may it be mining, making weapons or role playing. Again I think the library is a good source for information. It always is, right?
This might not have the complete answer but it may help. So we do not put a tag on the new player in a ‘guild’ that would possibly embarrass them and yet give them the chance to be the next best player this game has ever seen because we can all be that person if we want to. That is the beauty of this game, you can be anything you wish as long it is in character, the possibilities are endless!