Think about it like it would happen in real life. You walk onto a war scene, for whatever reason, and you see a bunch of people fighting. Not going to be easy to tell who are the 'good' and 'bad' guys. There doesn't have to even be a good or bad team. That would most likely be how the situation would happen in real life so consider how'd you'd rp when that was how it works.
Sorry, i wasn't really having a go at the lack of labels, more really the lack of being able to tell who was who.
How i saw it was that i could see the "bad" guys standing on top of the 2 towers. I could also see a mob below, which i assumed were the friendly mob coming to the rescue. However i found it impossible to tell where the chat was coming from. Seeing a bunch of "someones" trading insults doesn't help the rp. Also it made it very difficult to follow any meaningfull conversation, as all the somenes appear to talk at once, making it impossible to tell who was replying to what.
While it's more realistic than seeing the authors name before the chat comment, it really didn't help in this situation at all. In real life i would very quickly tune to certain voices and be able to to tell who roughly they were coming from, and also i would be able to recognise that voice later on if i heard it again perhaps.
Here's an example from the event, taken from my logs. Slightly edited to remove guildchat, /tells etc.
(21:04:29) Someone says: [yes]
(21:04:36) Someone says: [okies Izzy]
(21:04:37) Someone says: [you will have to find out IC when it starts]
(21:04:37) Someone says: [sorry]
(21:04:38) Someone says: [auto-accept for duels?]
(21:04:44) Someone says: [yes for duels]
((21:04:53) Someone says: [there WILL be fighting eventually]
(21:05:32) Someone says: [do you all have a group?]
(21:05:36) Someone says: There will be fighting when Edath shows up !!!!
(21:05:51) Someone says: oh ... wait .. Edath can't fight
(21:05:54) >Marthron Decksar takes a seat.
(21:05:58) Someone says: nevermind
(21:05:59) >Marthron Decksar stands up.
(21:06:22) Someone says: [if your on the bad side..and you need
an invite tell me xD Izzabella ]
(21:07:47) Someone says: [and thanks to those that introed]
(21:07:51) Someone inoocently asks: what is going on?
(21:07:53) Someone says: [lol who's shaking behind Maulus xD]
(21:07:57) >Mordaan greets Zetsumei.
(21:07:59) Auction from Someone: Buying platinum ore. 1k each. [Muday]
(21:08:43) Someone feels a wet warn liquid travel down one leg
(21:08:45) Someone says: ooer
(21:09:13) >Hulla greets Akashani.
(21:09:49) >Grizzlyus greets Perlan Cernun.
(21:10:07) >Zetsumei greets everyone.
(21:10:40) Someone shouts: [okay people if you're here cause you've here for the event you need to stop acting OOC and do something in town that your char would NORAMLY be doing here...if your on the good side you probaly dont know about what is about to happen!!! so go do something!]
(21:12:19) Someone shouts: [and put auto accept on--and rember you still will have to send a challenge itts not gonan be an open PvP]
(21:14:10) Someone shouts: *yells madly*
(21:14:55) Someone shouts: SO WILL WE SEEK DEMISE BY BORING EACH OTHER TO DEATH??!!
(21:15:21) Someone shouts: [TURN ON AUTO ACCEPT DUEL]
(21:17:50) Someone shouts: alright you miners! drop your picks!
(21:18:00) Someone shouts: this is war!
((21:19:11) Someone shouts: STOP put down your weapons!!!
(21:19:54) Someone shouts: I DONT WANNA DIE!
(21:20:06) Someone shouts: /me screams
(21:20:07) >Zetsumei takes a seat.
(21:20:26) Someone shouts: ahhhhhh
(21:21:02) Someone shouts: i'll give you anything PLEASE!
(21:21:08) Someone shouts: FIGHT!!
(21:21:36) Someone shouts: attention citizins of Gugrontid!!
(21:22:18) Someone shouts: My name is Izzabella and I am taking over this city of stone!
(21:22:41) Someone shouts: get out If you want to live!
(21:22:42) Someone shouts: I have hostages and I am NOT afraid to kill them!
(21:22:52) Someone shouts: GO AHEAD!
(21:22:57) Someone shouts: please!!! stop!!!!
(21:23:03) Someone shouts: I WANT TO LIVE!
(21:23:11) Someone shouts: Don't let me die!!
(21:23:11) Someone shouts: SOMEONE HELP!
(21:23:12) Someone shouts: NEVER!!!
(21:23:21) Someone shouts: I am not afraid to shed innocent life for the gain of my power!
(21:23:32) Someone scratches his head
(21:23:48) Someone shouts: swords for hire...
(21:23:57) Someone says: [looks like this is a waste of time]
(21:23:58) Someone shouts: does anyone want to negotate with me?
(21:23:58) Someone shouts: YOu are only someone
(21:24:06) Someone shouts: PLEASE DON'T KILL US!
(21:24:10) Someone says: ooer
(21:24:38) Someone says: methinks time to leave
this place
(21:24:44) Someone shouts: PLEASE!! DON'T!!!!!!!!!
(21:24:59) Someone shouts: SPARE US!!!
(21:25:01) Someone says: hehe, who is your target?
(21:25:18) Someone shouts: SPARE ME!!!!! I HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING WRONG!!!!!!!!
(21:25:21) Someone shouts: Heeelllppp
(21:25:28) Someone shouts: [uhh guy your skipping the RP part of the event..stop fighting yet!}
((21:25:34) Someone shouts: *guys
(21:25:41) Someone says: yup
(21:25:52) Someone rolls his finger at his head and looks at the crowd
(21:25:57) Someone shouts: STOP!! PLEASE!!!!
(21:26:24) Someone shouts: stop it!!
(21:26:28) Someone shouts: does anyone dare to negoate with me? or you hand this city of stone over to me and my gang?
(21:26:55) Someone shouts: charge!
(21:27:18) Someone shouts: stop!
(21:27:27) Someone shouts: MOve and they die!
(21:27:31) Someone shouts: my name is Izzabella and I am going to take over this city!
(21:27:44) Someone shouts: help me someone please,I'm a hostage
(21:27:46) Someone shouts: [stop fighitng! you have this is suposed to start as a RP evetn first!]
(21:27:56) Someone shouts: we have hostages and we are not afraid to kill them!
(21:28:06) Someone says: and who are you to claim it?!
(21:28:11) Someone shouts: I don't care who I have to kill to make you people listen!
(21:28:14) Someone shouts: boring!
(21:28:16) Someone shouts: PLEASE HELP!!!! I've not done anything wrong!!!!!!
(21:41:42) Someone shouts: help me help me help me
I'll skip a bit to near the end...
(21:41:58) Someone shouts: [I dont care if you have auto accept on or whatever but if are you challenged then you MUST accept]
(21:42:42) Someone shouts: [STOP!]
(21:42:50) Someone shouts: [SHUT THE TRUCK UP EVERYONE]
(21:43:12) >Mordaan greets Maanahr Ilde.
(21:43:18) Someone shouts: [wait! stop!]
(21:43:21) >Maanahr Ilde greets Mordaan.
(21:43:26) Someone sighs "i'll be in the bar..."
(21:43:34) Someone says: ditto
(21:43:39) Someone shouts: Screams to her death
(21:44:01) Someone shouts: HOW COULD YOU!?!?!?!?
(21:44:23) Someone shouts: Easy, all I had to do was push her.
((21:44:53) Someone shouts: HOW COULD YOU BE SO CRUEL?
??
(21:45:16) Someone shouts: Come on...don't fight...let's leave peaceful life on this world
(21:45:31) Someone shouts: [stop EVENT paused!}
(21:45:38) Someone shouts: leave each other a long
(21:45:51) Someone shouts: [ok]
(21:45:53) Someone shouts: [we have run into a problem and stop!}
(21:46:03) Someone shouts: [Izzy, what is it?]
(21:46:03) Someone shouts: stop
(21:46:05) Someone shouts: [what problem be that?]
(21:46:07) Someone shouts: [lack of realism?]
(21:46:22) Someone shouts: [okay I dont care if you have auto accept on or off..but if challenged you HAVE To accept!!!}
(21:46:37) Someone shouts: [a gm is on]
(21:46:38) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:46:41) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:46:42) Someone shouts: {I can't make everyone do..some are lagging to bad and they need to knwo who is after you]
(21:46:43) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:46:45) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:46:47) Someone shouts: [and why cant i kil
whats this crap]
(21:46:49) Someone shouts: {GM's ahve nothing to do with thie event]
(21:46:53) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:46:55) Someone shouts: we what pease
(21:46:59) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:03) Someone shouts: we what pease!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(21:47:03) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:04) Someone shouts: we what pease!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(21:47:05) Someone shouts: we what pease!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(21:47:06) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:08) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:10) Someone shouts: we what pease!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(21:47:10) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:11) Someone shouts: you said we should have one izzy]
(21:47:13) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!!!
(21:47:19) Someone shouts: KILL THE SPAMMER
(21:47:35) Someone shouts: we what pease!!!
(21:48:48) Someone shouts: [Kaerli STOP!}
(21:48:58) Someone shouts: [a frontal clash of the armies would be more realistic, by the way how did you manage to penetrate the city defenses, you just placed yourself inside an rped a raid?]
(21:49:15) Someone shouts: [PAUSE STOP KILLING!}
(21:49:31) Someone shouts: [I AM OUT OF THIS CRAP]
((21:49:42) Someone shouts: /me waves off and laughs "YOU WILL COME DOWN...AND WHEN YOU DO....."
(21:49:55) Someone shouts: RETREAT!
(21:49:56) Someone shouts: [I'm confused here, everyone needs to accept challenges = ought to be obvious]
(21:50:11) Someone shouts: [shout Kaerli we were PAUSED]
(21:50:16) Someone shouts: RUN!
(21:50:23) Someone shouts: retreat!
(21:51:27) Someone shouts: [i expected a better event. what a waste.]
(21:51:53) Someone shouts: [this sucks grand scale]
(21:52:49) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!
((21:54:04) Someone shouts: We want peace!!!
This log isn't intended to embarrass anyone, it's only as an example of how confusing it can be when your character doesn't know many people. Also i didn't seem to be able to /introduce myself to anyone that day either possible compounding my issues. If anyone (someone
) has a problem with their name in this log (I don't think there are many), let me know and i'll remove them.