* Under the moon reads Irgendwer's posts about the tutorial and is completely confused.
Is this the line that has you all riled up?
Xargon Guurn says: Excellent! Please remember to act in-character when talking to others. We are all working towards a roleplayed atmosphere in PlaneShift, regardless of the current client version. OOC -Out-Of-Character- text should be designated with parentheses or brackets, as regular text is that which comes from the mouth of your character, a person who lives in the world of Yliakum and knows nothing about computers, video games, the internet, or Picasso.
This line, his other rantings about the importance of roleplay and his constant inquireries if I have been paying attention. Phrases such as: " All right- now, my dear Sir, can you guess which word I am thinking of that starts with the letter 'R'?
We can now debate hours about how my subjective impression differs from yours and that I shouldn't have had it. This however does change the fact, that I had did.
To elaborate my impression after passing Xargon Guurn:
Aha, nice. A lecture on roleplay, written for idiots, telling me the dos and don'ts and constantly asking a question to make sure, I have read his lines. I may not enter the game till I have answered correctly. Erm ... "This website contains adult material (pr0n!). You may not enter unless you are of legal age (Enter/Leave)"? Ok, Question: If you are writing something for idiots, what makes you think, a genuine idiot will undertand it? What makes you think, a smartass will pay real attention? What makes you think a novice can roleplay without getting a bit familiar with the surroundings first and still has the turorial fresh in memory once s/he stumples in the first real RP situation?
Ok, someone here appearantly put quite a lot of time in writing a script, that will either tell nothing new to or overload the new player with information, just to stress out his/her point. Hm, this person was obviously a staffmember, making this the official stance of the dev team. Hm^2, this is a noncommercial project, meaning those people are working to get on what Blizzard et all won't give them to their satisfaction. Hm^3, what in the world could that possibly be (I think it starts with the letter "R")?
Ok, here we have a game, where SPUR can thrive and will find a very open ear. Do I want to have debates with a nitpick SPUR because s/he thinks my way of RP does not qualify as RP? No. Do I want the arguement to be constantly taken to the GMs? Certainly not! What can I do to avoid that? Simple: Keep to myself. No toes to step on that way.
I don't understand what you want either. No suggestion at all that [brackets] are preferred for OOC? Somehow making the dialogue 'gentler'?
1. Rethink the bracket rule. It does not work.
2. Rework the dialogue of the RP NPC. Strip it down to the bare minimums and try to rub it less into the player.
3. Rereading the chatlog, I think that a lot of what the NPC tries to teach you should actually go to your inventory in form of a handbook. That way you have it still around, when you need it (or have something to read while being exhausted).
The 'rule' about brackets evolved from players, not Devs. As the game evolved, players began using them more and more. The 'rule' was taught to new player by players, and still is. It has become part of the culture. The Devs can do -nothing- about that. The 'rule' is placed in there so new players do not get blindsided by people telling them how things are generally done in PS (sometimes in a not so nice manner if you run into a jerk). People who talk excessively OOC in open chat will get poked about it by other players. People who do it constantly are disrupting other players and will get warned by a GM.
If you read the Xargon Guurn chatlog again, you'll find, he teaches you this rule. Meaning it comes from the devs as far as the novice player is concerned. Stating, that I get warned by a GM for constantly using OOC (mind: Talking about stats is already perceived OOC. I don't need to mention "lightsabres", which by the way I am cabable and even willing to do in in IC fashion just to annoy a SPUR when s/he starts lecturing me) directly contradicts a statement made by you earlier, that this won't happen. This and the fact, that you are aware of players enforcing rules by themselves validates my point: The easiest way to avoid trouble is by either keeping to yourself (answering the question, what makes people not want to RP - see threat topic) or giving in to the stupidity and appease the rulenerds and SPUR by giving them their brackets. It will of course still be OOC, but now that it is savely contained within brackets, the deadly radiation it emits is shielded.
PlaneShift is a lot more exclusive in how we want players to act. If a player can not handle that, then this is simply not the game for them.
Sorry to say that, but: Welcome to SPUR camp. What you just said in these two sentences is this: If you cannot live up to our standards, which btw. nobody was ever able to define (so you cannot know if you are doing it right), you cannot play with us. Do I even have to elaborate more, why this stance makes people want to not roleplay? If I am a novice and happen to have a glimpse of this attitude (which is not that hard to get), I prefer to keep to myself. It spares me unpleasant debates.
Finally, we have the people that complain that the Chat is too restrictive around OOC and brackets. No, it is not a new complaint. It has been around ever since players started enforcing it themselves.
Maybe, just maybe this should ring a bell?
This rule is simply stupid. It is cumbersome to use and people mostly use it to be spared from rulenerd tells. By trying to be safe they commonly missaply it. I even saw a player once using them in her characterdescription, which is OOC by definition (unless stating visuals). An OOC free mainchat is an illusion. It won't happen and if you feel your RP experience being tainted by such things, there are better ways to deal with the situation then going OOC yourself and starting to lecture around. Some ideas include:
* Ignore the talk about e.g. "computers". Your character does not know what a "computer" is. Chances are, that you in reallife don't know what quantum physics are. This does not mean, that the persons talking about it don't.
* React to OOC topics with a blank stare. "Pardon me tabei, but this bug, that killed the server, you were talking about. Which type of clacker was that?" (this is called giving a good example and works FAR better then lecturing. Also it satisfies your RP needs, so it's a win-win situation).
* If a person constantly distracts you with OOC, simply use your mutelist. Chances are, that s/he'll never say something you are intrested in at all. This will keep your mainchat far cleaner then bracketed OOC talk.