Man, can't you guys focus?
All that matters is that the GM's should make an attempt at enforcing RP. Mainly because this is a Roleplay Game and not because some poll tells us so (even though both the poll and common sense are together on this one; If playing football is enforced when you're playing a football match [by the referees] so should RP be enforced when you're playing a RPG [by the moderators]).
However they do it, it's up with them. They've had enough hints over the years, so they should do fine.
And instead of thinking we're getting fascism here, consider that we're just making sure GM's make it so characters don't have horns where they shouldn't and that every player roleplays his own character (instead of typing "/me kills you") in a consistent way (according to settings and mechanics), without annoying people (avoiding abuses). Doesn't that sound like something we all want? Sure, so we have to give it a try.
Maybe I'd take out descriptions too, since most people can't use them (i.e. lots of people use them to post character's background or silly, impossible features.) In fact, I'd rather have "iconless", "sack-looking" items that would add "Is wearing *item*" to the description then having free editable descriptions that lead towards everyone having way too stupid descriptions. (Shadows hovering around, horns on Ylians, demon wings on diabolis, extra sexy characters, etc.) That's just me though, who cares, just as long as we have some nice moderation that can handle it. It would certainly reduce work though.