Sarva... You were around for this, so you could probably fill in some knowledge here, but in the past Myysst led some player-army, at the behest of the "Ochtarchy" in a player/GM event, right? Can you please tell us a bit about that? I heard Myysst mention it, but wasn't around for it and am thus foggy on the details.
It just seems to me that when the Octarchy gets a belly-full of the evil, smelly SPC, that they would send forth troops [in this case players, or GM characters if they felt so inclined] to shoo them away. Realistically speaking, there is no way for the Octarchy to patrol and enforce law in every corner of Yliakum. I'm a bit unclear too Gilrond, as how the PVP area makes this unrealistic? In a real life scenario, you wouldn't have needed to accept a challenge. A thug would have simply attacked/killed you at will. The way I see it, it's 100% more realistic.
And Jjairr - I read it because I talk to Ikon out of game

I think you'll enjoy it when it goes public.