Well think it's a good way to deal with it and might try it myself, but agree making it a forum post will probably just give ideas to the wrong kind of people aswell.

hhhhmmm addicted to catnip

Well don't see why smoking would be so bad. I mean a pipe seems to be pretty standard in fantasy and it's not like we don't see smoking in RL r something.

I really doubt it hasn't been used in some Rp already and the bubbling well just seems teletubbies in my eyes

hmmm if you already know the BD update you can't have been gone that long

hmmm I agree with Zanzibar with the repair system the modifier system seems a bit strange. I mean the ancient one I can imagine I mean after so long the whhole dagger just comes apart and no repairing would really fix it anymore, but the ragged and such are kind of strange with the repairsystem we have., but repairing is still relatively new so sure it will all be tweaked

Well I like the idea, but there is one flaw in what you have said so far.

Fighting should not be about playerskill

This is a roleplaying game after all were the roleplaying should play more of a role then in games like guildwars.

The fighting therefor in my opinion should also depends more on the skills of the role you play then on the skills of you as the player.

That is why I feel this idea is good but it might not suit Planeshift.

I think evil guilds attract players aswell...

Funny

hmm well if one massrecruits aparently you have something interesting aswell. Just some discusion on if people should join for those reasons

aahh but the exact math of how it works is a tradesecret ofcourse

*smiles*