Ok, the post that led me here made it sound like a tutorial thread, but the few posts in the thread I read made it sound more like a School, SO...I will comment on BOTH of them.
Ok, first things first...the tutorial...EXCELLENT IDEA. Have newbies earn a newberific training sword, some newbie armor and maybe a newbie backpack or bag, as well as some wonderful pocket change.
I think that for role play it should be quest form and involve as MUCH interaction between player and quest givers as possible. It should teach as MUCH of the communications, controls, where to and how to find trainers and how to get quests and what benefits they will give the player. They should encourage role playing and team or group playing. I think the first tutorial should even be non NPC for controls and how to get a quest from the tutorial quest NPC.
This quest should be a ONE time completed...ALWAYS completed (once and forever), so older players could not farm the newbie quest for ANY rewards it might give and the newbie swords value should either be NOTHING to merchants or close enough to not bother with the quest for that reason. (to avoid the make a new character just for the newbie sword, drop it log off and have main pick it up or other exploits).
And I think the second thread concept...the school, would be a GREAT idea. Earn some cash, go to the school and learn about the skill (class skill... potAtoe, potAHtoe, same thing different name, just like ranks/levels, same thing different name). I would like to see subjects on combining glyphs 101 (up to masters thesis), and Advanced dirty street fighting or the lonely path of the monk (aka fast fists and flying feet), maybe Botany 101 (or yes I promised you a rose garden, but I never said anything about NO thorns

), and herbalism 101 (or 1001 things you can do with garden weeds).
To me the \"school\" idea is beyond basic training, there should be significant benefits to taking the classes, they should be entertaining and educational. I am not sure what kind of costs should be in place since the current economy is so goofed that thinking of paying more than current training for ANYTHING hurts to much to think of it.